| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
JULY 2005 |
COVER STORY |
|||||||||||||||||||
|
EDITORIAL:
NEW LOOK, NEW CONTENT ![]() The copy of Siliconeer that you have in your hands has a completely new feel in both content and look. While readers have loved what we have provided, we have also received numerous requests to devote our focus to the dynamic and diverse South Asian community in its entirety, rather than focusing specially on technology or science. The argument made to us was simple: There are specialty periodicals to cater to the needs of those interested in technology and science, while the growing community deserves our full attention. We hear you, reader, and from this month Siliconeer will become a general interest magazine for the South Asian reader. While we are at it, we have done a complete revamp of the layout of the magazine (pending some tweaking and fine-tuning). We are proud to say that the magazine is comparable in design to any mainstream periodical. That’s no mean achievement. Mainstream magazines have a million-dollar revenue stream from advertising and subscription, while we continue to distribute the magazine free of charge. At Siliconeer we continue to change and evolve and seek new ways to make our magazine a better read and a more satisfying aesthetic experience. So the makeover is not the end, but the beginning. We hope to bring many changes to you in the future. Here’s a brief wish list, which we will implement as time and space allows. Book reviews. With s highly educated community as our readership, we have long felt the need of a section that informs our readers about the most stimulating and interesting books that are coming out. We don’t plan to limit ourselves to South Asian authors or subjects, either. Mainstream arts and culture. Siliconeer will try to break out of the ethnic cultural ghetto and take a peek at what’s going on outside the desi scene. Surely South Asians do not limit themselves to desi performing arts. Why should a magazine for South Asians? There is a wondrous world of art and culture out there theatre, ballet, cinema, you name it. Cricket. A passion for cricket is something many of us have brought with us from the old country, but looking at the mainstream media here, you wouldn’t even know the sport existed. Yet South Asians have a vibrant league here here, and most cricket aficionados keep a keen eye on developments in the cricket world. Politics. Outside the odd fundraiser for the local lawmaker who is happy to utter the standard bromides about the model minority, the community’s knowledge or involvements in politics is abysmal. Yet America is a dynamic democracy, and you ignore politics at your peril. Our focus will be mainly on issues that affect the South Asian minority. Other issues. We plan to cut a wide swath. Issues like civil rights, even when it does not directly involve South Asians, has long term implications for the community. We also plan to occasionally publish South Asian fiction, which may be contemporary or classical, or translated from Indian languages. What won’t change. Some things will remain the same, because they ought to. Every month, we will remain just as committed to providing you a compendium of well written and interesting articles in a format that is easy on the eyes. Although we have become a general interest magazine, we will continue to keep a keen eye on science and technology, it’ll just be part of a much larger pie. And we will continue to call ourselves Siliconeer. It’s true that given the current focus, the name does not fit the magazine as well as it used to, but it’s a name that has helped establish our reputation. It’s true Shakespeare once said: “What’s in a name?” but for once, we beg to disagree with the Bard. COVER STORY: Modadugu Gupta's Blue Revolution - A Siliconeer Report
The unassuming Indian scientist, whose research and grassroots work have helped fishery output skyrocket in countries like Bangladesh, India, Vietnam and Laos, has won the World Food Prize. A Siliconeer report. He’s an unassuming scientist, but his work has changed the lives of millions in some of the poorest parts of the world. Till the mid-1970s Modadugu V. Gupta was a scientist who was exploring ways to increase fish yields. But he was dissatisfied with the fact that his research was not translated into actual benefits for the impoverished rural folks who really needed it. So he moved from pure research to more hands-on work with grassroots organizations. His peers raised their eyebrows, but he didn’t care. What mattered was making sure the benefit of his scientific techniques didn’t get buried in some dusty report but actually made a difference in real people’s lives. In 2001, the Penang, Malaysia-based World Fish Center estimated that 1.04 million farmers/families practiced his low-input aquaculture technologies. Now, nearly 60 non-government organizations are working with these farmers to maintain and improve their aquaculture practices. This year, he has been named winner of the $250,000 World Food Prize for his work to enhance nutrition for over one million people, mostly very poor women, through the expansion of aquaculture and fish farming in South and Southeast Asia and Africa. Gupta’s name was announced by Ambassador Kenneth M. Quinn, president of the World Food Prize Foundation on June 10 at a ceremony at the U.S. State Department. Quinn said Gupta had been selected for this honor based on his work over three decades at the World Fish Center, a member of the Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research of the World Bank. “Through his dedicated and sustained efforts in Bangladesh, Laos and other countries in Southeast Asia , Dr. Gupta made small scale aquaculture a viable means for over one million very poor farmers and women to improve their family’s nutrition and wellbeing,” As a result of Gupta’s efforts, freshwater fish production has risen dramatically in these countries by as much as three to five times, he added. Gupta is the sixth citizen of India to receive the World Food Prize since it was established in 1986. Previous recipients include : Dr. M.S. Swaminathan, 1987; Dr. Verghese Kurien, 1989; Dr. Gurdev Khush, 1996; B.R. Barwale, 1998 and Dr. Surinder K. Vasal, 2000. “My research in India till 1976 was more of science developing technologies for high productions of fish from aquaculture,” Gupta told Siliconeer. “When I joined the United Nations Organization (its various agencies) in 1977 and worked in a number of developing countries in Asia and Africa till 2004, I have realized that what the poor, under-nourished, poverty stricken farmers need is not just scientific technologies, but technologies that take into consideration their resources and needs and that could be easily adopted by them. Realizing this, I closely worked with the rural farming communities and the NGOs who have been working at grass root level. Though the life was not easy, it gave me lot of satisfaction that my work could make much difference to these poor rural families, especially the women. Initially I was criticized by my peers that instead of doing research, I am doing development work. But once the impact of work was evident, every one was all praise for the work.” Commenting on his career with the World Fish Center, Gupta said, “In my early years at World Fish when I started working with farmers and NGOs in Bangladesh, I was asked why I was doing development work instead of research. My answer was that science by itself will not help to increase production and improve the lives of rural poor. Science must take into consideration the socio-economic fabric and needs of the societies for whom the research is meant.” His tenacity in finding means to improve the nutrition and living conditions of poor people through low-cost and accessible aquaculture technologies has contributed to a “blue revolution” in India. Two outstanding techniques developed to raise the productivity of aquaculture were recycling farm waste and polyculture. Using affordable and readily available farm waste such as chicken manure, rice bran and weeds, and culturing more than one species of carp with different food habits in the same pond, thus giving better utilization of available natural food produced in a pond, saw productivity beginning to rise in the 1970s and increasing to this day. Gupta was the first to start to break through the yield barriers and to do it with low-cost inputs. The national mean productivity per hectare climbed from only 0.5 tons per hectare in the early 1970s to an average of over 2 tons per hectare. Some farms increased production spectacularly and produced over 10 tons per hectare. In another region of Asia, the lower Mekong basin countries, and at around the same time, the late 1970s, fish farmers were struggling to raise species which did not grow quickly enough. Gupta turned to other species and found that certain species of native Indian major carps could flourish in the Mekong basin environment. He introduced this species to the Mekong basin countries along with the technologies to breed and raise them. There followed a proliferation of hatcheries producing fingerlings of Indian major carps species. Now, in the north of Vietnam, Indian major carps have come from nil supply to comprise about 30 to 40 percent of total freshwater aquaculture production. In the late 1980s Gupta worked closely with the Bangladesh Fisheries Research Institute to find ways to increase fish production through pioneering low-cost aquaculture technologies. The agro-ecological environment conditions differed in different parts of the country and they worked to integrate aquaculture in farming systems under these different conditions. The results were remarkable. One study showed that fish production increased nearly eightfold, from 304 kg/ha to an impressive 2,574 kg/ha in 3-6 months. Moreover, with the new technologies, farmers tripled fish yields in the difficult season between monsoon floods, achieving yields of more than 1,000 kg/ha. Furthermore, many unused small water bodies in Bangladesh were turned to productive use. Nearly half of the untapped resource of more than a million ponds, including seasonally-flooded ditches, and hundreds of thousands of small seasonal ponds and roadside canals were turned into a new source of food and income. The fish raised reduced protein malnutrition among the rural poor, especially those living in flood-prone areas. Gupta was the first to recognize the resource and to find ways to tap the fish-growing potential of these water bodies. “The diets of more than a million impoverished farmers and women in Bangladesh, Laos and other countries in Southeast Asia now include high-quality protein thanks to his 40 years of work,” the Des Moines Register has said in an editorial tribute to Gupta. “Congratulations to Dr. Gupta, and to the Food Prize committee for selecting such a worthy recipient.”
BUSINESS: Turning the Academic Tide: The Rush to India - By Siddharth Srivastava With India becoming a magnet for global outsourcing, Western business and management schools are keen to send students to find out what makes India tick, writes Siddharth Srivastava. One indicator that there is something good happening in an economy is when future corporate leaders of the world make it a subject of study. Indians heading to Western countries to pursue their dreams in education (there are 80,000 in the U.S.) is now commonplace. American and European students treading across to India for learning is a more recent phenomenon. Those who have come till now have mostly involved themselves in subjects like Sanskrit, spirituality, yoga, Ayurveda and Indian dance forms. But that’s changing. The Indian software sector, with last year earnings of $22 billion (exports over $17 billion) is one enterprise in which India is a leader. Topping the list for close observation as well as understanding are the two information technology giants, Wipro and Infosys, who have been at the vanguard of the software revolution. Both the firms have witnessed a huge jump in the number of management students seeking to make them part of their project coursework. Apart from credit-granting programs, many business schools in the U.S. have begun to bring students groups to India. Wipro has played host to a team of students from the Royal Institute of Stockholm and the Stockholm School of Economics. Recently, a team from Stanford visited Infosys and Wipro. Kellogg School of Management, Northwestern University, has a full-fledged program called Global Initiatives Management and is looking at offshore outsourcing as their topic of study. Students from the university will soon be visiting India. Schools like Wharton, Stern, MIT Sloan, Michigan, School of Management Boston plan to visit the country to build up knowledge in offshore sourcing. Recently, India was host to C. Jischke, president of Purdue University, the first president in Purdue’s 135-year history to visit India with the object of “globalizing” U.S. education. He is probably also the first head of a U.S. university who came to India to network personally and to talk to leading Indian institutes and identify subjects for study. “We are aiming at subjects India is strong in: engineering, pharmacy, management,” said Jischke. Jischke felt that with globalization, multinational firms with operations around the world will and have been showing preference for candidates who have had experience in study abroad as well as exposure to different cultures. “It demonstrates an ability to work in different environments at times more challenging,” he says. Purdue has already inked deals with the prestigious Indian Institute of Technology (IIT-Mumbai) as well as GE to arrange for short stints for students to imbibe a first-hand experience of the Indian syllabus as well as management style. Infosys, which is looking at attracting high-caliber professionals from around the globe, has a global internship program called InStep to introduce students around the world to Infosys and India. Infosys officials say that they have been receiving interns from colleges like MIT, Harvard, Stanford, Wharton, St Gallen (Switzerland), London Business School, Darmstadt (Germany) Hitotsubashi (Japan) and RMIT (Australia). InStep has received 3,000 applications for 33 positions this year. The company presently has interns from more than 12 different countries. In an interview Prabhudev Konana, professor at the McCombs School of Business, University of Texas at Austin, said he plans to bring a large contingent of students to visit India soon. The professor said since more than 50 percent of Fortune 500 companies and most other big global firms are looking at India for IT outsourcing, it is imperative for MBA programs to expose students to economic, political and cultural issues of doing business with India. The United States Education Foundation of India too has been involved in identifying India-specific study abroad programs that give American students a view of this country. Usefi has identified over 50 such packages, ranging from week-long to full-year to semester-long study options that can range from subjects such as religion and culture to law, engineering and the sciences. “India is strategically and culturally an important country for U.S. students. Knowledge of India is valued by universities,” says Jane Schukoske , executive director of Usefi. This, however, is not the first time that India has been involved in the education process of Americans. In what has been termed as outsourcing of education or e-learning, Indian e-teachers tutor students from the grade of 3-9 across America, sitting at their work stations in India due to shortage of teaching manpower in the U.S. Outsourcing companies such as Career Launcher, Educomp, Datamatics and NIIT have identified this opportunity that arose after the George W. Bush administration signed the No Child Left Behind Act with its multi-billion dollar funding. NCLB requires reading and math tests in grades 3-8 and high school. Of course when today’s global students come to get a first-hand feel of the information technology powerhouse that is India, it is an indicator that tomorrow’s professionals will follow or have already arrived. The interest of foreigners in Indian industry has been at two-levels one, high-end technology and multinational jobs (for example, in GE, Nokia) and two, language specific requirements further to India emerging as a hub of outsourced jobs catering to international customers. A recent research has pegged the potential demand of over 160,000 foreign language professionals in call centers and other back end operations by 2010. Estimates put the number of foreigners working in India in the software and outsourcing industries to be mounting at a rapid pace, the last count, as recorded in the foreign registrar’s office in New Delhi, having crossed 50,000 and growing. There are jobs up for grabs. Estimates suggest that 200,000 to 400,000 jobs have moved from the U.S. since the outsourcing trend began in the 1990s, which is still a fraction of 138 million jobs in the U.S. The most high-end projection is by Forrester Research a loss of 3.3 million jobs by 2015, including 1.7 million back-office jobs and 473,000 IT jobs which will create a dent in the U.S. job market but not the wreck everyone fears. Elsewhere, hardly a week goes by without Indian IT whiz kids hitting the jackpot somewhere in the world. In the most recent instance, two IIT graduates are set to become dollar billionaires by listing their internet gambling company, Party Gaming, in London. The London Stock Exchange flotation is expected to be worth $10 billion. It is the LSE’s biggest flotation since the $29 billion listing of Orange, the mobile telephone company, four years ago. The extraordinary entrepreneurial saga of an Internet upstart hitting the big league will redefine rules of wealth creation, and again, perhaps, provide ground for future study material. - Siddharth Srivastava is the India correspondent for Siliconeer. He is based in New Delhi. |TOP| NEWS DIARY: June Roundup Acquittal Suspended In Pak Rape CaseSPELLING BEE: Indian Kids Spell Victory WHITE HOUSE TRANSCRIPTS: Indira Gandhi a ‘Witch,’ Indians ‘Bastards’ Bail for Former Bangla Ruler’s Wife Indians: World’s Biggest Readers | BJP Drops Spokesman | Slow Response to Tsunami US Plea for Nepal Democracy | Communists Protest in India | Flood Shuts Power Project ‘Water’ to Open Toronto Fest | ‘Flood-scam’ Suspect Surrenders | Pranab Raises Heat Acquittal Suspended In Pak Rape Case Pakistan’s Supreme Court has suspended the acquittals of five men in a notorious gang rape case. The Lahore High Court had earlier acquitted the five who are accused of raping Mukhtar Mai in 2002, allegedly on a village council’s order.
The court ordered the men be detained in custody pending the appeal hearings. The Supreme Court agreed to suspend the acquittals following appeals by the 33-year-old woman and the government. Supreme Court Chief Justice Iftikhar Chaudhry said the court would re-examine the evidence. In his ruling, he ordered 14 men the five acquitted by the Lahore court, a sixth man whose death sentence was commuted to life imprisonment by that court and another eight men acquitted at the original trial be held in custody. “I am very happy, I am feeling satisfied,” Mai said. A village council allegedly ordered the rape because her younger brother was seen with a woman from the more influential Mastoi clan. “For many American contestants, the most uncommon words at last week’s national spelling bee were not appoggiatura and onychophagy, but the names of the top four finishers: Anurag Kashyap, Aliya Deri, Samir Patel and Rajiv Tarigopula. All were of Indian descent,” the newspaper wrote in a long article that commented on the propensity of Indian Americans to excel in this most quintessential of American institutions, the National Spelling Bee. To be sure, it’s not just the kids. Indian American parents are often passionately if not obsessively involved in training succssful kids.
The U.S. State Department declassified many documents this month on U.S. foreign policy of the time. One conversation transcript comes from the meeting between Nixon and Kissinger in the White House Nov. 5, 1971, shortly after a meeting with the visiting Indira Gandhi. “We really slobbered over the old witch,” says Nixon. “The Indians are bastards anyway,” says Kissinger. “They are starting a war there.” He adds: “While she was a bitch, we got what we wanted too. She will not be able to go home and say that the United States didn’t give her a warm reception and therefore in despair she’s got to go to war.” The Indo-Pakistan war took place between November and December 1971, following demands in 1970 by erstwhile East Pakistan (later Bangladesh) for autonomy, which became a demand for independence following an impasse in March. India supported Bangladesh and ties with the U.S. plummeted.
The 73-year-old general has also accused her of not divorcing her previous husband. The government has also filed charges, including one of money laundering. Bidisha was granted bail on all four cases. Neither the government nor Ershad has commented. Bidisha was previously married to British national Peter Wilson, with whom she has two sons. Before her arrest, Bidisha had been expelled from the Jatiya Party which her husband leads and in which she was a leading figure. Her lawyers say she is the victim of a political conspiracy within the Jatiya Party. The NOP World Culture Score index surveyed 30,000 people in 30 countries from December 2004 to February 2005. Analysts said self-help and aspirational reading could explain India’s high figures. Perhaps Indians have a healthy dislike of television and radio: India came fourth last in both. Thailand and China took second and third place respectively in average hours a week spent reading books, newspapers and magazines. Britons and Americans scored about half the Indians’ hours and Japanese and Koreans were even lower - at 4.1 and 3.1 hours respectively. R. Sriram, chief executive officer of Crosswords Bookstores, a chain of 26 book shops around India, told the BBC that Indians are extremely entrepreneurial and reading “is a fundamental part of their being.” Indian writer and editor, Tarun Tejpal, however, said the survey only made sense if it excluded the high numbers of illiterate Indians. Leading columnist Venkateshwar Rao told Britain’s Sunday Times newspaper he could not see Indians flocking to book stores. “Reading books just isn’t a habit with them because they’re not into cultural pursuits. It’s not a part of their make-up. All they want to do is consume.”
Sinha had publicly criticized BJP president L.K. Advani for describing Pakistan founder Mohammad Ali Jinnah as secular. The comments sparked a furor in India among Hindu hardliners. BJP leader Arun Jaitley told journalists in Delhi that the party had reshuffled its spokesmen, but did not specify why Sinha had lost his job. He said he and Sushma Swaraj, another BJP leader, would now speak officially for the party. Advani sparked the row during a visit to Pakistan in early June, when he spoke of Jinnah’s “forceful espousal of a secular state in which every citizen would be free to practice his own religion.” His comments caused an outcry in India. Despite over $3 billion in pledges, NGOs point to a lack of co-ordination and no clear plan. Over 30,000 people died in the tsunami and half a million were made homeless in Sri Lanka. The overwhelming need is for shelter, but so far across the country only around half of the temporary homes are up and only a few thousand of the 90,000 permanent homes needed have even begun construction. Six months ago, the only way to walk along the coastline in the southern town of Galle was to walk on the rubble of people’s fallen homes. Now that’s been removed. The debris has been cleared away and in its place has sprung up a chaotic mixture of wooden shacks and tents. Slowly the tents are going, but a lot of the transitional shelters that are replacing them are nothing more than huts. “Six months on people definitely should have been moved out of tents. There is no reason why they should be living in tents,” Malindi Langasinghe from the aid information centre in Hikkaduwa told the BBC.
The king seized direct power in February, saying politicians had failed to tackle the nation’s Maoist rebels. The U.S. and other countries criticized the move as a backward step. Camp, the U.S. principal deputy assistant secretary of state for South Asia, said that unity between the king and the parties was crucial to restoring democracy and tackling the Maoist insurgency. The parties have called for the reinstatement of the parliament that was dissolved three years, peace negotiations with the Maoist rebels and fresh national elections. The king has rejected the demands so far. Critics accuse him of seeking to return to the absolute monarchy. Camp said that a return to pre-1990 Nepal would be unacceptable to the world including the U.S. He also urged the Maoist rebels to declare a ceasefire and resume peace talks that broke down two years ago.
The left-wing parties, angry at the recent increase in fuel prices, also oppose the government’s policy of selling off some of its stake in state-owned corporations to raise funds for investment. India’s coalition government, led by the Congress Party, relies on four left-wing parties to maintain its majority in parliament. Police in the capital, Delhi, used batons and water cannons to push back hundreds of demonstrators protesting against the fuel price hikes. Protesters carried placards which read: “Take back petrol, diesel price hikes.” Elsewhere, trucks and commercial vehicles stayed off the roads as part of a “wheel-jam” called to protest against the hikes. Earlier, the communists had announced they were suspending participation in the policy co-ordination panel with the government. However, they said their protests were not aimed at bringing down the government. Thousands of people were left stranded after the level of the Sutlej river rose in Himachal Pradesh. They include several hundred tourists who are being rescued by helicopter. Twenty-nine foreigners are among those who have been evacuated. Although the level of water has receded, officials say they are still on a flood alert. “It is the high silt content which is forcing us to keep the (Nathpa) project closed,” a top official at the power project told the BBC. The Nathpa project houses Asia’s largest underground power complex and only came into operation last May. It supplies states across northern India as well as the capital, Delhi. It is not yet clear what caused the water level to rise but officials said it could be due to flooding in Parechu lake in neighboring Tibet, which has affected the Sutlej further downstream. The overflowing river destroyed villages, farmland and roads with the damage estimated at eight billion rupees ($183.7m). In 2000 floods on the Sutlej killed about 150 people in Himachal Pradesh.
Directed by Deepa Mehta, the movie follows the lives of Hindu widows. Filming in India was abandoned five years ago after hard line Hindu protesters burned its sets, claiming the movie distorted Indian culture. Filming was completed in Sri Lanka. Its world premiere will open the festival, which runs from 8 to 17 September. Water beat movies by better-known Canadian film-makers Atom Egoyan and David Cronenberg for the prestigious opening slot. Mehta, an Indian-born Canadian citizen, received death threats while shooting Water in north Indian city Varanasi. Although Time magazine dubbed him an “Asian hero” for his flood relief work, the former civil servant stands accused of siphoning off state funds for victims of monsoon floods that devastated Bihar last year. Goswami, who has denied misusing funds, has been in hiding for several weeks. “There is no scam,” he told the Indian Express. “The whole exercise was transparent. I don’t know why people are dragging my name into this. What I think is people are simply jealous of me.” The High Court in Patna has turned down his application for anticipatory bail. About 1,000 people died and millions made homeless in the flooding in Bihar last year. Goswami joined the S1 billion Sahara group, which has since sacked him. In its list of leading personalities from Asia last year, Time described Goswami as a “bureaucrat who saves India’s flood victims.” Bihar authorities announced an inquiry into the alleged diversion of funds in April. Mukherjee met with U.S. Vice-President Dick Cheney, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice and National Security Adviser Stephen Hadley during his trip. He told U.S. officials Pakistan President Gen. Pervez Musharraf is yet to dismantle the infrastructure of terrorism. Mukherjee’s initiative to put incremental pressure on Musharraf on cross-border terrorism comes only days after national security adviser M.K. Narayanan detailed at his meetings in with U.S. officials proof of Pakistan’s continuing efforts to destabilize Jammu and Kashmir and spread terror to other parts of India. DEVELOPMENT: Whither Bangladesh? Another Somalia or Another Malaysia? - By Mahfuz Anam Beneath all the bad news constantly coming out of Bangladesh, there are great things happening. However, if all its people don’t get engaged, Bangladesh may fall between the cracks, Mahfuz Anam told expatriate Bangladeshis in a speech. Here are excerpts. ![]() I am a journalist, so I will make sweeping comments. In my view, right now two Bangladeshs exist simultaneously. One Bangladesh is degenerated Bangladesh. A decaying, Bangladesh, which is rotting, stinking. A Bangladesh that is headed towards an abyss. At the same time there is another Bangladesh. This Bangladesh is regenerative, creative, changing, adaptive, innovative and moving forward. A big part of the degenerating Bangladesh is its rotting politics. Another is its backward bureaucracy. Another part is corruption. Another is a section of business. Almost all the awful things you hear about Bangladesh are true. But it’s not the whole truth. It’s only a part of the truth. The rest of the truth is that of regenerative Bangladesh Many NGOs are contributing towards the development of this Bangladesh, where a lot of community leadership is coming up, where an innovative, creative class of entrepreneurs are coming up, where educators, engineers, doctors, lawyers contribute, and Daily Star and Prothom Alo are also a very small part of this Bangladesh. Now which Bangladesh will prevail? The decaying Bangladesh, or the regenerative Bangladesh? That depends on where people like you and I stand. There is no room for sitting on the fence or being neutral here. Bangladesh can go down the road of Somalia or Bangladesh can become another Malaysia. But it won’t become Malaysia if we just sit it out. If we sit it out, it’ll surely go down the road of Somalia. I don’t want to castigate Somalia, I’m just taking it up as an example where the state is disintegrating and society is not progressing.
After living in a problem-ridden society for so long, perhaps we have forgotten how to acknowledge the positive. When I joined UNESCO in 1977, Paris had a substantial Middle Eastern population. Through my work, I made many Palestinian friends. You know, Palestinians are the brightest of the Arabs. They are most educated, they are doers. When my Palestinian friends would hear about our history, that after just a nine-month-long freedom struggle we became a free country, they would go green with envy. My Palestinian friends told me that they were born in the ’50s and ’60s, but they had never ever lived anywhere besides a refugee camp. I became conscious how lucky I was to be a citizen of an independent country, however problematic, however backward. If you look at a map of the world today, at least you can look at one country and say, “This is mine.” Something no Palestinian has ever had an opportunity to experience. I had once gone to Senegal while working for UNESCO. Senegal is a central African nation. Its western part touches the Sahara desert. I had to go there. For the first time I saw a desert. After talking to people there, I learned that not a thing grows there, and for a bucket of water, somebody from the family has to go out in the morning and return in the afternoon. I thought of verdant, riverine, bountiful Bangladesh, full of ponds, where if you through away the core of a mango it grows into a tree, where you can sleep in the outdoors eight months in a year. I became fully conscious how bountiful nature has been to us. Perhaps we are so overwhelmed by the problems that Bangladesh has, we have forgotten to realize the bounty that Bangladesh gives us. What we have failed to do is to manage Bangladesh. It is our fault, not Bangladesh’s fault. And that’s the primary message I am sharing with you. Let us now examine, in the midst of all the problems that we have, what has been Bangladesh’s achievement? If I concentrate on the last decade and a half, on an average Bangladesh’s GDP growth rate has been over 5 percent. Now if you look at the economic achievements of many countries of the world, an average of over 5 percent for more than a decade is a major significant achievement. We have had the beginnings of industrialization in Bangladesh. We have made some modest progress in the social sectors. We have the beginnings of, if you like, capitalism. The entrepreneurs, the free market, the beginnings of it are there. This is on the economic side. In politics, however flawed, we have a democracy in Bangladesh. Compared to Pakistan, compared to Nepal, I think in terms of developing a democratic society, as I said, however flawed, we have a semblance of democracy. The beauty of our democracy has been that in the last three elections all the time the opposition won. I think that is saying something. A country where the opposition always wins has something going for its democracy. But I do not for a moment want you to think that Bangladesh doesn’t have any problems. I think it is foolish to ignore Bangladesh’s enormous economic problems. But it is fatal to be overwhelmed by those problems. Let me use an icon in Bangla cultureour motheras a metaphor. There was a time when your mother was young, hardworking, beautiful, vivacious, perhaps sang as a hobby, did so many things. You were born to this mother. That mother of yours is sick, unwell today. She can’t do a lot of things she used to. Her looks are also not what they used to be. At a moment like this, are you going to constantly criticize your mother? Or are you going to gird your loins and get down to work to help ease your mother’s discomfort? I don’t think we have any alternative. Bangladesh is our country. Its limitations are countless. Its shortcomings are no less. There are many things my country doesn’t have. All the same, it’s my country. We were born there. Whatever success we have achieved, all credit goes to our motherland and family. With that claim of the motherland in mind, I ask you to join us in changing the future of Bangladesh. I believe it can be done. It is with that belief that I took my family back home to work. The good news for you is that a change is happening in Bangladesh. Perhaps not to the level that’s necessary, but we are also changing. We are becoming more modern, we are gradually becoming aware that to we need to change a lot if we are keep pace with the modern world. You will have to find the right partner. I just want to say that I am really, really bullish about Bangladesh. This is not a pie-in-the-sky optimism. I live in that country. I have seen how honest, decent, hardworking, ordinary folks are in Bangladesh. Bangladesh’s problem is its wealthy elite. The previous British high commissioner, after a four-year stint in Bangladesh, told me before leaving, “Mahfuz, I’ve lived in Bangladesh for four years, and I have traveled all around the country, and I am going back with the conclusion that you people are poor by choice.” What he meant was that there is no reason for Bangladesh to be poor. With a bit of effort we can get out of poverty. But we don’t do it because we lack long-term vision, and suffer from immature leadership, and a lack of earnestness. But all of this can be changed. We have to change it. We can change it. - Mahfuz Anam is editor of the Daily Star, Bangladesh’s leading English language daily. |